We live, we learn.

It has been almost three weeks since we heard from the President, and two weeks where I have found myself trending on Twitter. Neither of those things is optimal.


The Great DebaclePicture: @MalkopMedia


I’d really like to hear from the President – because we’re in crisis and it would be in everyone’s interest to know what the endgame is. When is level 4 morphing into level 3? Are we still flattening curves, or are we just paralysed in fear or ignorance? Will people be able to return to work? Nobody can plan their lives unless we know these things. And by we, I think I can safely say, all of us.

Gamers will know that in any strategy game (or even something as simple as Candy Crush), in order to win you need to know what the victory conditions are. In this COVID-19 crisis, we have no idea what those victory conditions are.

There is NO scenario in which not a single life is lost and there is NO scenario where we resume economic and social activity exactly as before. All public policy is a trade-off. The government needs to be honest and acknowledge either how many people we’re prepared to deprive of a livelihood, or how long we intend to attempt delaying the inevitable – because the deaths are inevitable, and lockdown will just stave them off for a few weeks or months. The WHO, Zweli Mkhize, Donald Trump, and every virologist, epidemiologist and public health expert agree on that. The people who will die from COVID, will die from COVID – because there is no cure and there won’t be for months or, as some might say, because it’s their time. This is no longer controversial. This disease knows the victory conditions. We are prevaricating.

What we can do is start planning our individual lives in line with what the government decides to do, and that’s why we need to hear from the President.

Being in the eye of the storm over the past two weeks has revealed how frightened and without agency so many South Africans are; how we hide behind tribal, racial and class barricades because we feel threatened, and how a small group of noisemakers think the rest of us shouldn’t have our say. I hope everyone starts writing open letters, making their voices heard and speaking up against police brutality, discrimination, price-gouging, unenforceable laws and power-drunk politicians. That’s the only way you know you’re free. Nobody owns you or your opinions, and you don’t have to conform like the Karen neighbour who reports you to the police, or the race-baiter who tells you that you aren’t allowed to say something because it makes you less black or white.

You don’t have to like me and I shouldn’t ever have to feature in your life again, but don’t feel like your voice doesn’t matter. The same people who keep telling me I have no right to speak out probably won’t want you to speak out either. Ignore them. We all count. Now more than ever.



‘The Big Debacle’


  • Nigel

    Just keep on Gareth. Please. The voices of reason and logic must overcome the screaming of the narrow and perverse. Just look at what Greta Thunberg has done. Really scary. Thanks

  • Dicky

    Only slight quibble with the idea that the exact same number of people will die. That is predicated on a health system having capacity. But it still means that you should have full hospitals and be trying to manage it through the population.

  • Nathi

    I agree with @Dicky, about the same number of people dying. Everything else is spot on. I just hold a view tht something very sinister is going on here. If we could close borders, not consume international news, work on our own vaccine or cure, and not listen to WHO, I would be very excited!!!

  • chukaman

    “you petty socialist” made my month and probably my whole lockdown. Yuss that was hilarious. My wife loved “intellectually bankrupt”. Anyway thanks for speaking for many of us 🙂

  • Kobus van Niekerk

    please never stop with what you doing. We all need to stand up against these puppets and their socialist way of doing and thinking.

  • Jason

    Go Gareth speak your mind we need a voice i been phoning for food since 26MARCH the government doesnot care..they useless

  • Troy Ounce

    When did flattening the curve turn into find finding the cure?
    They have us by the balls and will not let loose.

  • teeth

    When I originally commented I clicked the -Notify me when new comments are added- checkbox and now each time a comment is added I get four emails with the same comment. Is there any way you can remove me from that service? Thanks!

    • Dori

      I can’t see where to do that from my side unfortunately – maybe you have to do from your login? Or you can mark the emails as spam?

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>